A. Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973—Section 389(1)—Suspension of sentence—Stay of conviction—Distinct legal consequences—Exceptional relief—Held—Suspension of sentence merely defers execution of the sentence during pendency of appeal or revision, whereas stay of conviction keeps in abeyance the legal disabilities flowing from the finding of guilt—Stay of conviction is an exceptional remedy requiring compelling judicial justification—While exercising discretion, the Court must consider the irreversible consequences of conviction, including social stigma, loss of reputation and prejudice to personal dignity under Article 21—The power cannot, however, be exercised merely to serve political expediency or electoral ambitions. (Paras 9, 20-23)B. Constitution of India—Articles 14 and 21—Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973—...
A. Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988—Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2)—Demand and acceptance of illegal gratification—Proof—Death of complainant and shadow witness—Held—Proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification is a sine qua non for conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii) of the PC Act—Such facts may be established by direct or circumstantial evidence even in the absence of the complainant or shadow witness—However, mere recovery of tainted currency notes and positive phenolphthalein test, without proof of demand and conscious voluntary acceptance, cannot sustain conviction—Presumption under Section 20 cannot be invoked unless foundational facts are first established. (Paras 32-34, 40-44, 48)B. Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988—Section 20—Statutory presumption—Foundational...
A. Hindu Marriage Act, 1955—Section 24—Interim maintenance—Enhancement—Financial capacity of husband—Assessment—Held—While determining interim maintenance, the Court must consider the financial position, business income, investments, bank transactions and other financial resources of the husband—The appellant-husband was engaged in manufacturing auto cables through a partnership firm having annual turnover of Rs. 6.6 crores, maintained seven bank accounts, deposited Rs. 91 lakhs over two years and made a mutual fund investment of Rs. 16 lakhs—Having regard to the financial material and affidavits, enhancement of interim maintenance from Rs. 75,000 to Rs. 1,50,000 per month held neither perverse nor unreasonable. (Paras 2-5)B. Hindu Marriage Act, 1955—Section 24—Interim maintenance—Financial affidavits—Disclosure ...
A. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Sections 3 and 4—Proof of facts—Civil proceedings—Preponderance of probabilities—Held—In a civil suit, the plaintiff is required to establish the case on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities and not beyond reasonable doubt—Preponderance means a higher degree of probability and not a mere possibility—A Court cannot disbelieve an occurrence merely by describing it as suspicious or unbelievable without recording a finding that the witnesses are unreliable or their testimony is false—No fact can be assumed unless supported by evidence, documentary material or statutory presumption. (Paras 10-12)B. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Sections 146 and 155—Witnesses—Cross-examination—Impeachment of credit—Appellate appreciation of evidence—Held—The purpose of cross-examination is to ...
A. Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973—Sections 161 and 162—Statements to police—Hostile witnesses—Evidentiary value—Held—Statements recorded under Section 161 CrPC are not substantive evidence and can be used only for contradiction in the manner prescribed by Section 145 of the Evidence Act, 1872—Even where a witness denies having made the previous statement, the contradiction must be proved through the investigating officer—A proved contradiction may impeach the witness's credibility but cannot establish the truth of the facts narrated in the police statement—Previous statements of hostile witnesses cannot be relied upon to prove the accused's complicity or motive. (Paras 29-39)B. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Sections 25, 26 and 27—Disclosure statement—Discovery and recovery of weapon—Proof and evidentiary value—He...
A. Service Law—Probationary employment—Termination simpliciter—Motive and foundation—Distinction—Held—A probationer has no right to continue in service and may be discharged on the basis of a bona fide assessment of general suitability without holding a formal enquiry—However, where a specific allegation of misconduct is investigated and a finding of guilt forms the foundation of termination, the order is punitive notwithstanding its innocuous form—The distinction must be determined by examining the substance of the entire record and not merely the language of the termination order. (Paras 23-29, 38-40)B. Service Law—Probationary employee—Termination—Stigma—Judicial review—Pavanendra Narayan Verma test—Held—The Court must first examine whether the termination order is stigmatic on its face and, if not, whethe...
A. Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955—Rule 27(c)(4)—Departmental enquiry—Unauthorised absence—Opportunity to submit written statement and lead evidence in defence—Held—The procedure prescribed for departmental enquiry must afford the delinquent employee an effective opportunity to present his defence—The employee's medical prescriptions, pathological reports, medicine receipts and fitness certificate could not be discarded as fabricated merely because certain entries appeared to have been made with the same pen or the documents did not bear an indoor or outdoor patient number—In the absence of verification from the treating doctor, medical establishment or pharmacy, such inference rested on conjectures and surmises. (Paras 11-12)B. Central Reserve Police Force—Disciplinary proceedings—Unauthorised absence—Wilfu...
A. Central Industrial Security Force Rules, 2001—Rule 36—Departmental enquiry—Principles of natural justice—Supply of documents in language understood by delinquent employee—Denial of defence assistance—Held—Where the employee was not conversant with English, furnishing Hindi translations of relied-upon documents only after examination of prosecution witnesses and closure of evidence deprived him of an effective opportunity to defend himself—Denial of assistance of a defence assistant, in the circumstances of the case, further vitiated the enquiry—Findings of the Inquiry Officer unsustainable. (Paras 21-22)B. Central Industrial Security Force Rules, 2001—Rule 36—Departmental proceedings—Misconduct—Proof of charges—Past service record—Previous minor penalties—Held—Charges of deliberate disobedience and int...
A. Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017—Sections 2(119), 2(30), 8 and 9—Schedule II, Note 6—Solar Power Generating System—EPC contract—Composite supply and works contract—Distinction—Held—Every composite supply does not constitute a works contract—A works contract must relate to construction or installation of immovable property—Solar photovoltaic panels/modules merely affixed to a civil foundation for stability and capable of being detached and relocated without damage remain movable goods—Such affixation does not result in permanent beneficial enjoyment of the foundation—Supply and installation of SPG systems, therefore, cannot be treated as works contract merely because the EPC contract includes civil works. (Paras 20-29, 35-36)B. Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017—Section 9—Notifications Nos. 1/20...
A. Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985—Sections 15 and 18—Rehabilitation scheme—Scaling down of unsecured liabilities—Binding nature—Held—A rehabilitation scheme sanctioned by the BIFR is binding on all concerned, including unsecured creditors and creditors whose claims crystallise subsequently—Creditors cannot opt out of the scaled-down settlement or seek recovery of full dues after expiry of the period stipulated in the scheme—The option under Clause 11.11 permitting unsecured creditors to await the scheme's completion or seven years and thereafter claim full dues was invalid—STC, whose claim was classified as a contingent liability, could at best claim treatment at par with unsecured creditors upon crystallisation of its dues. (Paras 5-6, 12-16)B. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016—Sections 8 ...
A. Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989—Section 3(1)(r)—Intentional insult or intimidation—Essential ingredients—Held—Every insult or intimidation of a member of a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe does not constitute an offence under Section 3(1)(r)—Prosecution must prima facie disclose intentional insult or intimidation with intent to humiliate the victim on the ground of his belonging to a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe—Mere caste status of the victim, without the requisite caste-based intention, is insufficient to attract the provision—Principles laid down in Swaran Singh v. State, (2008) 8 SCC 435, Hitesh Verma v. State of Uttarakhand, (2020) 10 SCC 710 and Shajan Skraria v. State of Kerala, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2249, reiterated. (Paras 8-10, 14)B. Scheduled Castes and Schedule...
A. Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988—Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2)—Demand and acceptance of illegal gratification—Essential ingredients—Held—Proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification is sine qua non for establishing offences under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2)—Mere recovery or acceptance of money allegedly by way of bribe or undue pecuniary advantage, in the absence of proof of demand, is insufficient to establish criminal culpability—Demand and acceptance may be proved by oral, documentary or circumstantial evidence. (Paras 18-20)B. Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988—Section 7—Presumption under Section 20—Nature and applicability—Held—Upon proof of foundational facts constituting the offence under Section 7, Court is mandated to raise the legal presumption that illeg...
A. Indian Penal Code, 1860—Section 498-A—Cruelty—Extra-marital relationship—Held—Mere existence of an extra-marital relationship, without more, does not by itself constitute cruelty within the meaning of Section 498-A—Prosecution must establish wilful conduct of such nature as is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide or cause grave injury or danger to her life, limb or health, or harassment with a view to coercing her or her relatives to meet an unlawful demand for property or valuable security—Allegations confined to husband's relationship with another woman and transfer of properties in her favour did not satisfy either limb of the Explanation to Section 498-A. (Paras 25-27)B. Indian Penal Code, 1860—Section 498-A—Ingredients of cruelty—Specific allegations—Held—General, omnibus and vague allegations, witho...
A. Indian Succession Act, 1925—Sections 59 and 63—Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Sections 67 and 68—Will—Proof of due execution and attestation—Burden of proof—Held, The burden of proving a Will lies upon the person propounding it, who must establish that the testator signed the document, was in a sound and disposing state of mind, understood the nature and effect of its dispositions and executed it voluntarily—A Will required by law to be attested cannot be used in evidence unless at least one attesting witness is examined to prove its execution, if such witness is alive and capable of giving evidence—The propounder must satisfy the prudent mind by cogent and satisfactory evidence. (Paras 15-16)B. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Sections 67 and 68—Indian Succession Act, 1925—Section 63—Will—Proof of execution—Examinati...
A. Criminal Procedure Code, 1973—Section 378—Appeal against acquittal—Scope of appellate interference—Double presumption of innocence—Held, Appellate Court may reappreciate the evidence in an appeal against acquittal, but interference is justified only where the acquittal is manifestly illegal, perverse, wholly unsustainable or results in miscarriage of justice—Where two reasonable views are possible on the evidence, the view favourable to the accused must prevail—Due weight must be given to the findings of the Trial Court, which had the advantage of observing the demeanour of witnesses. (Paras 12-13)B. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Section 3—Criminal trial—Benefit of doubt—Material contradictions—Improvement in testimony—Held, Where the informant materially improved upon his initial statement by introducing new fact...
A. Constitution of India—Article 226—Industrial Disputes Act, 1947—Labour Court award—Writ jurisdiction—Scope of judicial review—Maintainability—Held, The High Court, while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226, does not act as an appellate forum for routine reappreciation of evidence or substitution of findings recorded by the Labour Court—However, interference is permissible where the award suffers from patent illegality, perversity, non-consideration of material evidence or erroneous application of statutory provisions—Writ petition raising such grounds cannot be rejected at the threshold as not maintainable. (Paras 7-10, 41-45)B. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947—Sections 25-B and 25-F—Retrenchment—Completion of 240 days of continuous service—Burden of proof—Held, Completion of 240 days of continuous servic...
A. Constitution of India—Article 22(1)—Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023—Section 47(1)—NDPS Act, 1985—Section 52(1)—Arrest—Communication of grounds of arrest—Constitutional safeguard—Held, Requirement of informing an arrested person of the grounds of arrest is mandatory and the investigating agency bears the burden of proving effective communication of sufficient knowledge of the basic facts constituting such grounds—Where the grounds are not communicated, the arrest and subsequent remand stand vitiated and statutory restrictions on bail cannot defeat the constitutional right to liberty—However, where grounds have been served but are deficient in detail, prejudice caused to the accused is relevant. (Paras 11-20)B. Constitution of India—Article 22(1)—NDPS Act, 1985—Section 37—Communication of grounds of...
A. Transfer of Property Act, 1882—Sections 6(h) and 7—Transfer of immovable property—Purchase in the name of a minor—Validity of title—Benami plea—Held, Purchase of immovable property in the name of a minor through a registered sale deed does not suffer from any legal disability or invalidity merely because the transferee was a minor at the time of purchase—Defendant, who was not a legal heir of the alleged real purchaser and did not claim through him, could not challenge the title of the recorded purchaser by setting up a plea of benami transaction. (Paras 37-41)B. Transfer of Property Act, 1882—Sections 54 and 7—Registered sale deed—Transfer of ownership—Proof of execution—Hospital execution—Held, Plaintiff established the valid transfer of the suit property through the registered sale deed dated 20.11.1975 by ...
A. Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996—Section 11—Appointment of arbitrator—Dispute arising from electricity supply agreement—Scope of arbitration clause—Held, An arbitration clause providing for reference of disputes arising out of or in connection with the agreement must be read along with its express exceptions—Disputes concerning recovery of consumption charges, minimum charges, miscellaneous charges and other charges, or matters for which a determination mechanism is prescribed under the governing Acts, Rules, Regulations and conditions of supply, stand excluded from arbitration. (Paras 22-23)B. Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996—Section 11—Electricity Act, 2003—Sections 61, 62, 63 and 86(1)(a)—Electricity tariff—Dispute regarding applicability of amended tariff order—Jurisdiction of Electricity Regulat...
A. Land Acquisition Act, 1894—Section 18(1)—Reference for enhancement of compensation—Acceptance of compensation without protest—Effect—Held, A land loser who accepts the compensation amount without protest and thereafter, after more than five years, files an application seeking enhancement cannot maintain a reference under Section 18—Where the conduct of the landowners does not indicate any intention to challenge the award at the time of receiving compensation, the bar under Section 31(2) applies. (Paras 18-19, 21)B. Land Acquisition Act, 1894—Sections 18(1) and 31(2)—Acceptance of compensation—Determination of protest from conduct—Held, No specific proforma is prescribed for expressing protest while accepting compensation—The intention of the landowners must be gathered from their conduct—Where an application see...