A. Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Rules, 1981—Rule 36—Departmental inquiry—Inquiry Committee—Bias—Close familial relationship between adjudicator and complainant/witness—Held—A departmental inquiry must be conducted by an independent, impartial and unbiased decision-maker—Where the Convenor of the Inquiry Committee is the real brother of the management Secretary, who simultaneously acts as complainant, principal witness and prosecutor, and is personally interested in the outcome of the inquiry, the close familial relationship gives rise to a reasonable likelihood of bias—Actual bias or proof of a specific instance of prejudice is not necessary to vitiate the inquiry. (Paras 34-49, 51-55)B. Constitution of India—Articles 14 and 21—Principles of natural justice—Bias—Test of reasona...
A. Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973—Sections 156(3) and 197—Maharashtra Amendment Act 33 of 2016—Sanction for investigation against public servant—Acts allegedly committed in discharge of official duty—Held—Prior sanction under Section 197 CrPC and Maharashtra amendment to Section 156(3) is required only where the act complained of is committed while acting or purporting to act in discharge of official duty and bears a reasonable nexus with such duty—Protection cannot extend to acts of forgery, fabrication of documents, criminal conspiracy or cheating merely because opportunity to commit such offences arose from official position—Quality of the act complained of, rather than the official position of the accused, is determinative. (Paras 30-35)B. Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973—Section 197—Prosecution of public servant...
A. Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973—Section 389(1)—Suspension of sentence—Stay of conviction—Distinct legal consequences—Exceptional relief—Held—Suspension of sentence merely defers execution of the sentence during pendency of appeal or revision, whereas stay of conviction keeps in abeyance the legal disabilities flowing from the finding of guilt—Stay of conviction is an exceptional remedy requiring compelling judicial justification—While exercising discretion, the Court must consider the irreversible consequences of conviction, including social stigma, loss of reputation and prejudice to personal dignity under Article 21—The power cannot, however, be exercised merely to serve political expediency or electoral ambitions. (Paras 9, 20-23)B. Constitution of India—Articles 14 and 21—Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973—...
A. Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988—Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2)—Demand and acceptance of illegal gratification—Proof—Death of complainant and shadow witness—Held—Proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification is a sine qua non for conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii) of the PC Act—Such facts may be established by direct or circumstantial evidence even in the absence of the complainant or shadow witness—However, mere recovery of tainted currency notes and positive phenolphthalein test, without proof of demand and conscious voluntary acceptance, cannot sustain conviction—Presumption under Section 20 cannot be invoked unless foundational facts are first established. (Paras 32-34, 40-44, 48)B. Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988—Section 20—Statutory presumption—Foundational...
A. Hindu Marriage Act, 1955—Section 24—Interim maintenance—Enhancement—Financial capacity of husband—Assessment—Held—While determining interim maintenance, the Court must consider the financial position, business income, investments, bank transactions and other financial resources of the husband—The appellant-husband was engaged in manufacturing auto cables through a partnership firm having annual turnover of Rs. 6.6 crores, maintained seven bank accounts, deposited Rs. 91 lakhs over two years and made a mutual fund investment of Rs. 16 lakhs—Having regard to the financial material and affidavits, enhancement of interim maintenance from Rs. 75,000 to Rs. 1,50,000 per month held neither perverse nor unreasonable. (Paras 2-5)B. Hindu Marriage Act, 1955—Section 24—Interim maintenance—Financial affidavits—Disclosure ...
A. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Sections 3 and 4—Proof of facts—Civil proceedings—Preponderance of probabilities—Held—In a civil suit, the plaintiff is required to establish the case on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities and not beyond reasonable doubt—Preponderance means a higher degree of probability and not a mere possibility—A Court cannot disbelieve an occurrence merely by describing it as suspicious or unbelievable without recording a finding that the witnesses are unreliable or their testimony is false—No fact can be assumed unless supported by evidence, documentary material or statutory presumption. (Paras 10-12)B. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Sections 146 and 155—Witnesses—Cross-examination—Impeachment of credit—Appellate appreciation of evidence—Held—The purpose of cross-examination is to ...
A. Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973—Sections 161 and 162—Statements to police—Hostile witnesses—Evidentiary value—Held—Statements recorded under Section 161 CrPC are not substantive evidence and can be used only for contradiction in the manner prescribed by Section 145 of the Evidence Act, 1872—Even where a witness denies having made the previous statement, the contradiction must be proved through the investigating officer—A proved contradiction may impeach the witness's credibility but cannot establish the truth of the facts narrated in the police statement—Previous statements of hostile witnesses cannot be relied upon to prove the accused's complicity or motive. (Paras 29-39)B. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Sections 25, 26 and 27—Disclosure statement—Discovery and recovery of weapon—Proof and evidentiary value—He...
A. Service Law—Probationary employment—Termination simpliciter—Motive and foundation—Distinction—Held—A probationer has no right to continue in service and may be discharged on the basis of a bona fide assessment of general suitability without holding a formal enquiry—However, where a specific allegation of misconduct is investigated and a finding of guilt forms the foundation of termination, the order is punitive notwithstanding its innocuous form—The distinction must be determined by examining the substance of the entire record and not merely the language of the termination order. (Paras 23-29, 38-40)B. Service Law—Probationary employee—Termination—Stigma—Judicial review—Pavanendra Narayan Verma test—Held—The Court must first examine whether the termination order is stigmatic on its face and, if not, whethe...
A. Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955—Rule 27(c)(4)—Departmental enquiry—Unauthorised absence—Opportunity to submit written statement and lead evidence in defence—Held—The procedure prescribed for departmental enquiry must afford the delinquent employee an effective opportunity to present his defence—The employee's medical prescriptions, pathological reports, medicine receipts and fitness certificate could not be discarded as fabricated merely because certain entries appeared to have been made with the same pen or the documents did not bear an indoor or outdoor patient number—In the absence of verification from the treating doctor, medical establishment or pharmacy, such inference rested on conjectures and surmises. (Paras 11-12)B. Central Reserve Police Force—Disciplinary proceedings—Unauthorised absence—Wilfu...
A. Central Industrial Security Force Rules, 2001—Rule 36—Departmental enquiry—Principles of natural justice—Supply of documents in language understood by delinquent employee—Denial of defence assistance—Held—Where the employee was not conversant with English, furnishing Hindi translations of relied-upon documents only after examination of prosecution witnesses and closure of evidence deprived him of an effective opportunity to defend himself—Denial of assistance of a defence assistant, in the circumstances of the case, further vitiated the enquiry—Findings of the Inquiry Officer unsustainable. (Paras 21-22)B. Central Industrial Security Force Rules, 2001—Rule 36—Departmental proceedings—Misconduct—Proof of charges—Past service record—Previous minor penalties—Held—Charges of deliberate disobedience and int...