A. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Order XXXIX, Rule 4—Temporary injunction—Discharge, variation or setting aside—Change in circumstances—Where injunction order has been passed after giving the affected party an opportunity of hearing, it cannot be discharged, varied or set aside on that party’s application unless such relief is necessitated by a change in circumstances or the Court is satisfied that the order has caused undue hardship—Power under the proviso is not available for re-agitating grounds already considered while granting injunction. (Paras 6-8)B. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Order XXXIX, Rule 4—Change in circumstances—Meaning and scope—Subsequent communications from bank requiring production of injunction order, mortgage of another property and repayment of loan, along with valuation report of suit proper...
A. Indian Succession Act, 1925—Sections 59 and 61—Will—Testamentary capacity—Undue influence, coercion and fraud—A Will is not rendered invalid merely because the beneficiary has persuaded the testator, shown affection, given expensive gifts or provided attention, provided the testator retains sound disposing mind and exercises free judgment and volition—Illustrations (vii) and (viii) to Section 61 expressly recognise that persuasion, attention and flattery do not invalidate a Will in the absence of fraud, coercion or loss of free agency. (Paras 31-32, 51-55)B. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Sections 68 and 69—Indian Succession Act, 1925—Sections 59 and 63—Proof and execution of Will—Attestation—Propounder examined an attesting witness, who established that the testatrix gave instructions voluntarily, understood the con...
A. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Section 100—Second appeal—Substantial question of law—Concurrent findings of fact—Held, High Court cannot interfere with concurrent findings of fact merely because another view of the evidence is possible. Interference is warranted only where findings are perverse, based on no evidence or affected by an error of law. Where the findings of the Courts below are supported by the evidence on record, no ground for interference is made out. (Paras 20-21)B. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Partition—Oral partition—Family arrangement—Proof—Held, a genuine family arrangement may be oral and is not invalid merely because it is not reduced to writing. However, the party asserting such arrangement must establish its existence and the specific allotment claimed. Appellant's failure to prove oral partit...
A. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Order 39, Rule 2-A—Disobedience of injunction—Proof of breach—Evidence of third parties—Held, where the petitioner-company had examined its authorised signatory and two witnesses and the documentary evidence established that the respondents had sent emails to various authorities containing the alleged defamatory statements, the application could not be rejected merely for non-examination of the persons or authorities to whom such emails were addressed. The contents of the emails were self-explanatory and the trial Court’s insistence on independent evidence from the recipients was erroneous. (Paras 20-22)B. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Order 39, Rule 2-A—Proceedings for breach of injunction—Appreciation of evidence—Remand—Held, rejection of an application for breach of injunction on t...
A. Indian Penal Code, 1860—Section 395—Dacoity—Identification of accused—Held, where the incident allegedly involved 20 to 22 persons, who entered the house at 1.30 a.m. with their faces covered, during rainfall and absence of electricity, identification of the appellants in the light of a kerosene lamp required careful scrutiny. Mere familiarity of the witnesses with the appellants could not remove the doubt arising from the circumstances of identification. (Para 12)B. Indian Penal Code, 1860—Sections 395, 337, 342 read with Section 34—Appreciation of evidence—Interested witnesses—Previous enmity—Held, evidence of related witnesses cannot be discarded merely on account of relationship; however, admitted partition disputes, pending civil and criminal proceedings and previous complaints between the parties were relevant c...
A. Indian Penal Code, 1860—Sections 498-A, 306, 107—Matrimonial cruelty—Abetment of suicide—Essential ingredients—Held, mere unnatural death of a married woman or existence of matrimonial differences is insufficient to establish abetment of suicide. Prosecution must establish that the deceased committed suicide and that the accused intentionally instigated or aided its commission, satisfying the ingredients of abetment under Section 107. In absence of evidence establishing the necessary ingredients, conviction under Section 306 cannot be sustained. (Paras 17-20)B. Indian Evidence Act, 1872—Dying declaration—Reliability—Voluntariness—Medical evidence—Held, a dying declaration can form the sole basis of conviction only when the Court is satisfied that it is voluntary, truthful and made in a fit state of mind. Surrounding...
A. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Section 24—Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005—Sections 25(2), 26—Transfer of proceedings—Wife seeking transfer of husband's application for modification of maintenance and alternate accommodation allowance from Magistrate Court to Family Court, where matrimonial proceedings were pending—Section 26 of DV Act enabling Family Court to grant reliefs under Sections 18 to 22, but not conferring jurisdiction to decide modification application under Section 25(2)—Magistrate who passed original order held to be competent forum for its modification on changed circumstances—Transfer under Section 24 CPC impermissible unless transferee court is competent to decide the proceeding—Application dismissed for want of jurisdiction and absence of justifiable hardship or inconvenience. (Par...
A. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Order 21 Rules 97, 99, 100, 101 and 103—Execution of decree—Objection by third party claiming independent right, title and interest in immovable property—Nature of adjudication—Held, An application under Order 21 Rule 99 raising an independent claim to possession requires adjudication of the right, title and interest asserted by the objector—Where such application is adjudicated on merits, the determination is conclusive between the parties and the order is treated as a decree under Rule 103, carrying the same consequences as to appeal—Rejection of an objection under Rule 97 or Rule 99 after consideration on merits is therefore challengeable by way of appeal and not by writ petition. (Paras 4, 6)B. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Order 21 Rules 99, 101 and 103—Executing Court—Rejection of...
A. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Order XXI Rules 64, 65 and 66—Execution of decree—Sale proclamation by public auction—HELD—The provisions prescribe a statutory scheme governing the sale of attached property in execution of a decree. Substantial compliance with Order XXI Rule 66(2) was established where the decree-holder furnished the terms of settlement, the property was sufficiently described for identification, and the judgment-debtors failed to specifically dispute the particulars or furnish an alternative valuation report. An objection regarding undervaluation, unsupported by a valuation report before the Executing Court, could not be raised for the first time in writ proceedings. (Paras 13-17)B. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—Order XXI Rule 64—Sale of attached property—Extent of property to be sold—HELD—The object...
A. Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881—Section 142(2)(a)—Dishonour of cheque—Territorial jurisdiction—Payee’s home branch—HELD—Where a cheque is delivered for collection through an account, territorial jurisdiction lies with the Court within whose jurisdiction the branch where the payee or holder in due course maintains the account is situated. Under the Explanation to Section 142(2)(a), delivery at any branch of the payee’s bank is deemed to be delivery at the branch where the payee maintains its account. (Paras 8-11)B. Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881—Section 142(2)—Retrospective application—HELD—The 2015 amendment governing territorial jurisdiction in complaints under Section 138 applies retrospectively, as held in Bridgestone India (P) Ltd. v. Inderpal Singh. Jurisdiction must be determined under the amended provi...